CALIFORNIA EVIDENCE: CIVIL AND CRIMINAL
...Privileges
......Privacy Privilege
6 Cards On This Topic:
  • Right to privacy recognized in Cal. Const.
  • W may seek discovery of evidence that H knew or should have known he had HIV and relevant sexual history, limited to window created by H’s negative HIV test; W may overcome limitation by giving basis to question test’s accuracy.
  • Fourth Amendment privacy interests did not prohibit collecting D’s blood for convicted offender DNA database.
  • When discovery of private information found directly relevant, must still be careful balancing of compelling public need for discovery against fundamental right of privacy.
  • Communications disclosed during mediation before ombudsperson employed by private educational institution are protected by qualified privacy privilege.
  • Right to privacy still relevant even where individual records discoverable; must balance privacy w/need to ascertain truth.